Following the declaration of unconstitutionality of the acquisition of the institute's healing art. 43 Presidential Decree No. 327 of 2001, employment in the case of sine titulo a fund for the construction of public works, should apply to Articles 934 et seq. of the CC, with the result that, according to the rule accession, the the private landowner has the right to restitution, in addition to compensation for damage suffered, being irrelevant after implementation of a public .
E 'this innovative principle expressed by the TAR Campania, Sec. V, in s Entenza No 262, January 18, 2011 .
Following the decision of the Constitutional Court No 293, 2010 [link to Bosetti & Gatti] that declared unconstitutional the institute employment acquisitive, two scenarios were envisaged. One solution, perhaps more obvious, but also more dangerous recalling the decisions of the ECHR 2000, was to reverse the situation before the introduction of the system unconstitutional art. 43, providing for the "revival" of the Institute dell'accessione inverted array of case law, involving the automatic transfer to the PA of private property as a result of its irreversible transformation. The second, more striking, and inclined to accede to the demands of European origin, included a general survey buoyancy Italian law in order to find a suitable answer to the "regulatory gap" so formed.
E 'is this the road taken by the comments made in the TAR Campania, which tracks the rules applicable to employment with no qualifications in the general institutions of civil law regarding the conditions for the acquisition of the property. According to the judges of Campania, in fact, who builds on ground work of others does not become owner of that land just because it is a government that works for a public purpose , but on the contrary, under the general rule on the accession dictated by the Articles. 934 and 936, paragraph 1 of the Code, is the owner of the land that captures the work, maintaining the right to believe or to oblige the one who has made to eliminate it, and of course the damage suffered . If the solution is certainly in line with the European authorities, it seems legitimate to ask whether the same decision would be taken in the event of demolition of public works of major or strategic work.
Workarounds have been proposed by other cases. Of these, cited TAR Puglia, Lecce, Sec. I No 293 of 2010, referred to by the judges and Campania, which proposes the implementation of the specification of the institute art. 940 cc In this way, the specific (in our case the government) would be credited to the property for originario sia della cosa nuova che del fondo sul quale insiste. Tale istituto, tuttavia, non solo è stato previsto dal legislatore per le cose mobili (e non per quelle immobili), ma per di più pare far rientrare dalla finestra l’istituto dell’accessione invertita, ritenuto dalla CEDU in contrasto con l’art. 1, protocollo n. 1, della Convenzione Europea dei Diritti dell’Uomo.
E 'this innovative principle expressed by the TAR Campania, Sec. V, in s Entenza No 262, January 18, 2011 .
Following the decision of the Constitutional Court No 293, 2010 [link to Bosetti & Gatti] that declared unconstitutional the institute employment acquisitive, two scenarios were envisaged. One solution, perhaps more obvious, but also more dangerous recalling the decisions of the ECHR 2000, was to reverse the situation before the introduction of the system unconstitutional art. 43, providing for the "revival" of the Institute dell'accessione inverted array of case law, involving the automatic transfer to the PA of private property as a result of its irreversible transformation. The second, more striking, and inclined to accede to the demands of European origin, included a general survey buoyancy Italian law in order to find a suitable answer to the "regulatory gap" so formed.
E 'is this the road taken by the comments made in the TAR Campania, which tracks the rules applicable to employment with no qualifications in the general institutions of civil law regarding the conditions for the acquisition of the property. According to the judges of Campania, in fact, who builds on ground work of others does not become owner of that land just because it is a government that works for a public purpose , but on the contrary, under the general rule on the accession dictated by the Articles. 934 and 936, paragraph 1 of the Code, is the owner of the land that captures the work, maintaining the right to believe or to oblige the one who has made to eliminate it, and of course the damage suffered . If the solution is certainly in line with the European authorities, it seems legitimate to ask whether the same decision would be taken in the event of demolition of public works of major or strategic work.
Workarounds have been proposed by other cases. Of these, cited TAR Puglia, Lecce, Sec. I No 293 of 2010, referred to by the judges and Campania, which proposes the implementation of the specification of the institute art. 940 cc In this way, the specific (in our case the government) would be credited to the property for originario sia della cosa nuova che del fondo sul quale insiste. Tale istituto, tuttavia, non solo è stato previsto dal legislatore per le cose mobili (e non per quelle immobili), ma per di più pare far rientrare dalla finestra l’istituto dell’accessione invertita, ritenuto dalla CEDU in contrasto con l’art. 1, protocollo n. 1, della Convenzione Europea dei Diritti dell’Uomo.
La sentenza T.A.R. Campania, Napoli, sez. V, 18 gennaio 2011, n. 262, é disponibile sul sito Giustizia Amministrativa a questo indirizzo .
0 comments:
Post a Comment